Environmental Group Blames San Onofre Leak on Equipment Change

Friends of the Earth says SoCal Edison installed untested technology, which led to a lengthy plant shutdown. Meanwhile, the NRC reiterates pledge to keep the plant closed until source of problem is found and fixed.

A design change that dodged federal inspection caused the that has sidelined San Onofre's nuclear power plant, an environmental group said Tuesday.

When Southern California Edison installed new, $671-million steam generators at the plant, it didn't tell regulators about a key design switch, allowing the equipment to sidestep NRC inspection, according to a report by nuclear expert Arnie Gundersen.

Gundersen, who works for Fairewinds Associates, a nuclear energy consulting firm, was hired by Friends of the Earth to analyze the plant shutdown. He based his conclusions on design documents and other reports by Southern California Edison on the company's decade-long effort to replace steam generators and upgrade the San Onofre plant, completed in 2010.

Edison spokeswoman Jennifer Manfre denied any deception and said safety was the top priority at the plant.

"At all times during the steam generator replacement process and the ongoing outages in Unit 2 and 3, Southern California Edison has provided open and transparent information to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission," she said via email. "SCE's top priority is the health and safety of the public and our workers. As is standard practice in the nuclear industry, SCE has been conducting tests and inspections as part of an in-depth  analysis. SCE has been committed from the beginning to not returning Unit 2 or Unit 3 to service until we are satisfied it is safe to do so."

Edison won't be allowed to restart the plant until the NRC determines the root cause of the leak and makes sure Edison fixes the problem, she said.

Meanwhile, Edison continues to test the tubes, hundreds of which have shown unexpected wear in their walls.

One expert said. And the Independent System Operator, which oversees allocating electricity in California,

The January leak happened in tubes containing super-heated, high-pressure radioactive water that has touched the nuclear fuel. This water is supposed to stay in a closed loop, while fresh water is circulated outside the tubes to make steam that turns a turbine and generates electricity.

At least eight of the 129 tubes identified will have to be welded shut before the plant restarts; they failed pressure tests.

Gundersen's report attributed the wear to several factors, including a change in the metal alloy used in previous generators, which had lasted more than 40 years, plus a change in the apparatus that separates the tubes from one another.

Fairewinds said these untested design changes allowed the tubes to vibrate as the super-heated water rushed through, causing the walls of the tubes to wear down prematurely.

An NRC letter issued Tuesday afternoon confirmed that vibration and friction between the tubes and support structures caused the wear, but technicians have not yet determined why the vibration happened. A copy of the NRC press release and letter is attached to this article.

Among other things, it .

According to Fairewinds, Edison also falsely told the Nuclear Regulatory Commission there were no significant design changes in the new steam generators, which it described as a "like for like" replacement. This allowed Edison to sidestep inspections, the report states.

A PDF copy of the full report is attached to this article, as is a video featuring Gundersen when .

Gene Stone March 28, 2012 at 02:15 AM
The people at SONGS who did this should go to jail for this. "Safety first" how does that work when things like this go on all the time? Now we will have to watch these crooks to make sure they don't plan power outrages like 10 yrs ago when Gray Davis was Gov and they raised the price on us. They already started the "brown out fear campaign".
David Lv March 28, 2012 at 04:43 AM
Every engineer knows that flow induced vibrations can start from even minor changes in design. San Onofre apparently made multiple changes without partial or full scale testing. Oops. This is the end of these power plants. No one will allow new generators to e installed again. This just goes to show that younger engineers and managers place too much faith in computers vs realworld testing. What other engineered machines such as bridges, airplanes, ships, etc are not being teted correctly? Scary.
Patti Davis March 29, 2012 at 03:18 AM
I will trust Arnie Gundersen over SC Edison every day of the week! SC Edison has proven that they can not be trusted. They have put our health, our children's health, our safety and our property all at a horrible risk. There is no excuse for this. This is not acceptable. We have to protect ourselves. Download, Sign and Share the California Nuclear Initiative. http://sanonofresafety.org/california-nuclear-initiative/print-petition/


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »