Opinion: No Breaks for Billionaires

Rancho Bernardo's Charlie Williams argues that job growth, not tax cuts for the rich, is what will ensure a strong economy going forward.

By Charlie Williams 

Black Friday and the weekend following saw millions of American consumers rush to our nation’s shopping outlets, spending an estimated $50 billion in just in four days of shopping and bringing smiles to many business owners. $50 billion seems like a great amount of money and indeed it is. But my curiosity got the best of me so I decided to compare those four days of all that spending to the accumulated wealth of just one of America’s richest billionaires, Bill Gates. Surprisingly our Black Friday spending didn’t measure up to the wealth of Mr. Gates who is reported to have a net worth of $59 billion dollars as of 2011. 

It is not this writer’s intention to criticize Bill Gates or any of the other 402 billionaires for their huge success in accumulating wealth. But it only seems fair that those so well rewarded should be asked by Congress to share some of their wealth for the good of our country. I suggest starting with eliminating the Bush tax cuts that helped propel our nation’s richest to record earnings and record corporate profits. After all, our billionaires and thousands of multi-millionaires have done very well in recent years while many millions of other Americans suffer job losses, even losing their homes and in many cases all of their life savings, not to mention the horrible mess left of our economy.

History tells of the robber barons of the late 19th and early 20th centuries who also amassed huge wealth much like the billionaires of today. But a bit of sympathy is due the robber barons of old as they actually built job-creating industries like railroads, and factories, from steel manufacturing to chewing gum as recently reported by Jeff Madrick on the NYR Blog. Unlike the robber barons of old, many of the robber barons today made much of their money through  investment gambling while producing very few products. This new investment industry actually promotes closing American factories and shipping our jobs out of the country. Investors then bring their low-wage produced products back to America to sell, driving up profits at the expense of American workers’ jobs. Today’s robber barons have even invested in schemes that ensure both their success and their failure thereby ensuring they profit if they win or if they lose.

Congress has helped to make today’s robber barons much richer while devastating our economy and . Those in Congress who insisted on tax giveaways as the answer to job growth have been proven wrong time and time again. Our economy started to tank as early as the year 2007, swiftly accelerating throughout  2008 all the while causing millions to lose their jobs, their homes and their life savings. Cutting their taxes gave trillions of our wealth to the super rich while engaging our nation in two wars, adding even more trillions to our economic debt by diverting trillions from our U.S. Treasury. If tax cuts to the super wealthy while engaging in two wars were the answer to economic growth as promised, then why did our economy tank? The case has been made abundantly clear that tax cuts, especially for the super wealthy, are not the answer to economic growth—not then, not now, not ever.  Yet today’s congressional Republicans are steadfast in refusing any consideration toward eliminating or even scaling back Bush tax cuts to the wealthy.

While corporate America and their super rich friends have profited well since the Bush tax cuts were put in place, some 16 million American children are living in poverty. That is one child in four, according to Nov. 27 report about poverty in America on CBS' 60 Minutes. Growing poverty, and its dire effects on our families, is somewhat like a dropped anchor on a ship, designed to ensure no movement, only in this case we appear to be drifting backwards. 

Labor force’s share of the percentage of national income fell to a nearly 60-year low, according to a Dec. 2 HuffPost Business article, noting that "though employers may be experiencing a growth in productivity, the rise in income is going towards company profits, not workers." That same article pointed out that the income of the top 1 percent of earners grew by 275 percent between 1979 and 2009 while the bottom fifth of earners experienced a mere 20 percent rise in their income during the same period, as reported by the independent Congressional Budget Office.

Organized labor and workers in most every field are under constant attack from the ultra right all throughout this great country. As I pointed out in a Patch column in August, titled “," as unions' membership rolls decline, so does America's middle class and both have been declining at an equally alarming rate for the past 30 years.

Black Friday weekend shopping and all shopping for that matter is good for our economy. Even former President George W. Bush would often urge that we go shopping during his years as president. But apart from Black Friday weekend shopping, there is no real expectation of a return to consistent high volume shopping as today’s shoppers continue to struggle with stubbornly high unemployment rates. So just urging us to go shopping is not the answer in today’s economy.  

Congress must help and should begin by passing President Obama’s “jobs bill” which is much needed at this time in order to prime our economic pump.  Accelerating job growth will allow workers to purchase homes, cars, appliances and other necessities which in turn ensures the hiring of millions of new workers. Congress must get serious about job growth and address the inequality of our current tax system. By doing so, Congress will have taken a big step forward toward restoring the American middle class and an economy that serves the needs of all the people, not just the privileged few. Restoring fairness throughout society, from the richest to the poorest alike, is the right and just thing to do and will ensure many returns of future profitable Black Fridays.

Charlie Williams is chairman of Field Mobilization Committee, Alliance for Retired Americans and former Midwest States Political Director for the Machinists Union.

Tony Padilla December 07, 2011 at 02:58 AM
Mr. Charlie Williams, you make a great analysis of an economic tragedy. Unfortunately, unless some of those leaders in congress wake up, they will destroy the middle class who pays the bill for this economic disaster. Congress is punishing the working class with unfair and unbalanced assessment of taxes while giving tax breaks to millionaires and billionaires and this must stop. You make a great point that the economy will not improve and that unemployment will not improve by giving those tax breaks to the wealthy; because, if this was true our economy and job market would not be in this situation. The Republican leadership does not want to tax the very rich. Some wealthy individuals have pleaded to be taxed just a little more, but they were chastised and criticized, because, although they are rich, they are not the billionaires in those corporations that collectively are much more wealthy than just mere millionaire individuals proposing tax fairness. Charlie, your are so right that President Obama’s “jobs bill” would boost the economy. Workers can pay their bills and their mere livelihood’s survival. Politicians use Christ and Christianity in their campaigns but they do the opposite in Congress of what Christianity means. Hopefully the citizenry will make judgment at the voting booth in the upcoming 2012 elections. While this year the retailers on Black Friday did very well, the unemployed and underprivileged truly suffered a gloomy Black Friday
Kennie Eastwood December 19, 2011 at 10:36 PM
Every one except bonehead of ohio and the rich gop has known this since the wars started and most intelligent people knew the rich was going to pull the rug on the housing when there pockets were to full to hold more.Does anyone in the GOP/TEA party live in the real world in the 21 centry?
Tony Padilla December 20, 2011 at 06:31 AM
Charlie, you are so right. As long as the Bush-Tax continues to exist through extensions, the American Workforce will continue to deteriorate. The rich can continue to make their profit but By-God pay a little more attention to the inequity for the sake of public necessity of Jobs. Yes, the far Right Republicans and TEA party extremist must be stopped. They are indeed destroying the middle class, but, they are doing it by design. Republican Presidential hopeful Newt Gingrich said, that if elected president, he would replace janitors in schools with children. He was talking about the Hispanic children so they can get the training they need to be responsible. What an asinine thing to say. Republicans want to eliminate agencies such as the Labor Department and the Department of Education to destroy Unions. There are few jobs and unemployment is high. Most everything is made in other countries. Propaganda that President Obama fails to enact legislation that would put an end to this economic atrocity is misleading. Congress makes the laws. I hope that in the upcoming 2012 elections the people vote for Obama and Democrats who share their views on the issue of Jobs, Taxes, and programs to save Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. Let it be Black Friday every day so workers can afford to participate.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »